Do Unto Others As You Would Have Them Do Unto You
We’re constantly explaining the Golden Rule to our kids – don’t do something to someone if you wouldn’t like it done to you. Treat someone the way you would want to be treated.
But really, that’s a lie.
It works when you’re five. When your kid comes crying to you because their friend won’t play with them, and you have to tell your kid to stop pestering their poor friend who clearly needs a break… only to have your kid come crying to you five minutes later because a different friend won’t leave them alone… that’s when you remind them of how they felt FIVE MINUTES AGO.
The Golden Rule assumes that you lack basic empathy, and that you need to remind yourself that other people have feelings, too. If you don’t like to be punched in the face, your friend probably won’t like it either, imagine that! But once you have achieved simple empathy, the Golden Rule stops being useful, because there are a LOT of exceptions.
Maybe you are an extrovert, and when you have had a bad day, your best cure is a fun night on the town. But if your coworker is an introvert, then the worst thing you could do is bully them into going out with you after a bad day, because their cure is a quiet night in their pajamas with a book.
Maybe you are a cuddler, and you love to give and receive hugs. But if your best friend needs a large bubble of personal space, then you are disrespecting her feelings and needs if you insist on constantly putting your arm around her.
And if you are a Star Wars fan but your friend hates it, would you give them a Star Wars themed shirt for their birthday? Of course not.
Treating others the way you want to be treated, instead of the way THEY want to be treated, is at the very best insensitive and at the very worst, abusive.
The real rule is this:
Do Unto Others As They Would Have You Do Unto Them
That’s easy enough when it comes to respecting someone’s personal boundaries or buying them a Christmas gift that they would really like. But when your spouse wants to be treated in ways that you would consider abusive, it’s pretty hard to wrap your head around.
I can’t begin to describe how much I would abhor being ordered to fetch a drink, scolded for being sassy, verbally degraded, or punished with a spanking. Like, I-would-leave-the-relationship levels of abhorrent. So it is really hard for me to try and treat my partner that way. It sets off all of my empathy alarms.
It’s hard to understand that they are false alarms. Those alarms are tripped by decades of following the Golden Rule. I have spent most of my life trying to be nice, trying to be considerate, trying not to be selfish or hurtful or demanding or cruel. I have done this partly because society demands it, especially of girls and women, and partly because I am so deeply hurt by a cutting remark, and I don’t ever want to make someone feel like that.
But here I have my husband ASKING me to do those things. Hell, he keeps buying me books about how to do them better!
It’s hard. It’s REALLY hard. It’s hard to overcome years of conditioning, shut down those Golden Rule/Empathy alarms, and actually remember how HE feels about it, and what HE wants.
It’s going slowly. I know I’m being too nice. I keep saying please when I tell him to get me a drink. I make excuses for him when he slacks on his chores. I fret over his feelings. Is this still okay? Does he really enjoy this?
He has to keep reminding me that he wants this. He has to keep making a point of telling me, “I really enjoyed that. That was good.” I have explained to him that I need to hear this – that I need him to validate every tentative step I make toward being the domineering, impatient, insulting Queen of his dreams. I have warned him that it will be slow going. You can’t overcome three decades of social conditioning overnight. But I believe that I will get there. I believe that deep inside, I AM selfish and impatient and domineering. I’ve just kept that self suppressed for a very, very long time.
If I’m going to draw it out of myself, I need my Adoring Slave by my elbow thanking me for doing it and assuring me that yes, this is how he wants to be treated.
Even though it isn’t the way that I would want be treated myself.
The Golden Rule is no longer valid here.